ECHENG.COM and TOW.COM present...

A Superficial Canon 1Ds, 1D, and D60 Comparison


Comparison 1: Darth Maul, Candle, and Powerbook [back to index] [prev] [next]

The three cameras were positioned on tripods in approximately the same location. Shots were fired in RAW mode and were converted using Adobe's RAW plugin using default (as-shot) parameters.

This was an interesting experiment because we can clearly see that at the same distance from a subject the Canon D60 captures MORE detail than does the Canon 1Ds, at the same focal length. The 1Ds captures more detail than does the Canon 1D. Note that I'm defining "more detail" as meaning that there are more pixels if you crop in to capture the same element in the composition.

For example, you shoot a shot of an apple with each of the three cameras and then crop each photo so that the apple fills the frame. The D60's apple will be the largest, in terms of pixel size, followed by the 1Ds, and then the 1D.


Canon 85/1.8, f8 for 2 seconds, ISO 200
Resized to 600 pixels wide and saved as jpg 70%. No sharpening applied.

    600x400 @ 100% crop from image
Saved as jpg 70%. No sharpening applied.
 
Canon 1Ds - Full Frame
  Canon 1Ds - 100% Crop
 
       
Canon 1D - 1.3X Focal Length Multiplier
  Canon 1D - 100% Crop
 
       
Canon D60 - 1.6X Focal Length Multiplier
  Canon D60 - 100% Crop